Products

2 dozen shooters Key Lime & Biscoff Cheesecake
Sold out
$2.00
Sold out
Assorted Colored Shooters
$50.00

Assorted Colored Shooters

Comes in a variety of flavors up to 3 flavors. With maximum of 2 color of choices.  Must text 904-552-5505 with flavor choices. 

$50.00
Assorted Shooters 1 Dozen
$47.00

Assorted Shooters 1 Dozen

The assorted comes with 12 Shooters with your choice of up to 3 flavors. Upon ordering add flavors in notes.  Note: If you want to order custom/the...

View full details
$47.00
Banana Pudding Shooters
$42.00

Banana Pudding Shooters

1 dozen classic shooters 

$42.00
Bananas
$0.00

Bananas

$0.00
Biscoff Cheesecake
Sale
from $13.50

Biscoff Cheesecake

Light & Fluffy Cheesecake pudding with Biscoff cookie crust, topped with Biscoff cookies and caramel.   *Does not include bananas*  Can be adde...

View full details
from $13.50
Sale
Biscoff Nana
from $13.00

Biscoff Nana

Think about a Classic banana pudding. We added a twist and added Biscoff cookies & caramel instead.

from $13.00
Butterfinger
from $13.50

Butterfinger

Butterfinger pudding paired with Cara's Crust.   Does not come with Banan

from $13.50
Cara’s Classic Crust Nana-less Pudding
from $12.50

Cara’s Classic Crust Nana-less Pudding

Vanilla wafer crust, classic Banana pudding without bananas

from $12.50
Cara’s Classic Nana Crust
from $12.50

Cara’s Classic Nana Crust

Vanilla wafer crust, classic Banana pudding with bananas

from $12.50
Classic Nana pudding
Sale
from $12.00

Classic Nana pudding

Traditional Banana pudding

from $12.00
Sale
Classic Pineapple
from $12.50

Classic Pineapple

Classic Banana pudding with a twist.... pineapples added for a refreshing taste.

from $12.50
Color Add On
$6.00

Color Add On

Please put in notes the color of your choice. 

$6.00
Colored Banana Pudding Shooters
$35.00

Colored Banana Pudding Shooters

1 dozen colored shooters. Please text 904-552-5505 with color of your choice. 

$35.00
Confections by Cara Gift Card
from $10.00

Confections by Cara Gift Card

Need a gift idea? Gift Cards are Perfect for any occasion.

from $10.00
Custom Shooters
$58.00

Custom Shooters

All shooters can be customized to your liking. Min of 12 must be purchased. We can customize according to your theme. There will be additional char...

View full details
$58.00
$15.00

Delivery Fee

Only for catering orders. Absolutely no personal orders. 

$15.00
Dozen Cheesecake Biscoff Shooters
$42.00

Dozen Cheesecake Biscoff Shooters

Shooters only come in a dozen minimum. $3 each min 12.

$42.00
Extra Caramel
$0.75
Extra Cookies
from $1.00

Extra Cookies

When ordering extra cookies please make sure you order for the size pudding you are purchasing.  Ex: Small puddings should be ordered with small ex...

View full details
from $1.00
Extra Crust
from $1.00

Extra Crust

Vanilla wafer crust

from $1.00
$80.00

Extra Large

This pan is an extra large pan that's bigger than a cake size pan. It will feed up to 30 people. 

$80.00
Extra Pineapples
from $1.00
Extra Strawberries
from $2.00
Half Dozen Shooters
$20.00

Half Dozen Shooters

Comes with 6 5oz shooters

$20.00
Half of Dozen Assorted
$22.50

Half of Dozen Assorted

2 Flavors

$22.50
Key Lime
Sale
from $14.00

Key Lime

Key Lime pudding, Graham cracker crust. 

from $14.00
Sale
No Banana Classic Pudding
from $13.00

No Banana Classic Pudding

We like to call this our cookie pudding with no ban

from $13.00
Nuts
$1.00

Nuts

$1.00
Oreo Delight
from $13.50

Oreo Delight

Oreo Pudding with Oreo cookie crust, topped with Oreos and Oreo crust.    *Does not include bananas*  Can be added if like

from $13.50
Party Tasting Samples
$29.00

Party Tasting Samples

These are for catering orders only. Choose Flavors by adding the flavors as a note. PLEASE do not place as a personal order. The fee attached will ...

View full details
$29.00
Pineapple banana pudding shooters
$45.00

Pineapple banana pudding shooters

1 dozen Pineapple banana pudding. Can be ordered with cheesecake pudding or banana pudding. Please list in the notes what flavor.

$45.00
Pineappple Cheesecake
from $13.50

Pineappple Cheesecake

Pineapple, Cheesecake & Crust

from $13.50
Red Velvet Cake/Cheesecake
from $14.00

Red Velvet Cake/Cheesecake

If you are a Confections by Cara fan we normally carry Red Velvet cheesecake with Red Velvet cookies, This time we have Red Velvet Cake.

from $14.00
Reese’s Buttercup
from $14.00

Reese’s Buttercup

A blend of  Reese’s Buttercup pudding, with vanilla wafer crust.   *Does not include bananas*  Can be added if like.

from $14.00
from $13.50

Strawberries & Pineapples Banana pudding

This has strawberries & pineapples with bana

from $13.50
Strawberry Banana
Sale
from $13.50

Strawberry Banana

Classic Banana Pudding with Strawberries

from $13.50
Sale
Sale
from $10.00
Sale
Strawberry Cheesecake Delight
from $13.50

Strawberry Cheesecake Delight

Glazed Strawberries, Cheesecake Pudding, Topped with Vanilla Wafer Crust.   *Does not include bananas*  Can be added if like.

from $13.50